Doctoral Program
Requires the completion of coursework, language requirement, two qualifying examinations, and a dissertation. Normal time to completion is four years.
Important information you will need during your academic studies at the Centre. For more detailed information, please refer to the Graduate Handbook.
Program Requirements
Supervisor and Committee
Each student writing a thesis must have a Thesis Supervisory Committee.
Supervisor
The supervisor plays a key role in the direction of the student’s research. The supervisor(s) must be a member of the Centre for the Study of Theory and Criticism's Core Faculty. Every effort will be made to accommodate the student's research preferences and supervisor; however, the program cannot guarantee a particular supervisor.
In term 4, the first term of the second year (September–December), students must, in consultation with the Graduate Studies Committee (GSC), identify a dissertation research area and select an appropriate supervisor. This information must be submitted in writing to the Program Coordinator.
Supervisor selection: In consultation with the Program Director and the core faculty, students should identify a thesis topic and secure a thesis supervisor and second reader by the end of Term 4. Begin by reviewing the research profiles of the core faculty. Once you have identified one or more faculty members whose research aligns with your interests, approach them to discuss potential thesis topics and their availability to serve as your thesis supervisor. Once a faculty member has agreed to supervise your thesis, you should identify and secure a second reader.
Second Reader
An additional core faculty member, preferably from a discipline different from that of the thesis supervisor, who provides independent academic guidance and an additional disciplinary perspective on the development and direction of the thesis. The second reader offers feedback throughout the research process but is not expected to review the thesis in its entirety. The second reader also serves on the thesis hearing committee (see below) and the thesis examining committee.
Associate Faculty may serve as 2nd readers on MA and/or PhD theses provided they possess proper SGPS membership in their home department.
For more information, please see the Graduate Regulations and SGPS Thesis Examination Guide.
Course Requirements
Graduate courses in other programs concerned with theory and criticism may also be approved, with the permission of the Director and Graduate Studies Committee (GSC). Students may take up to two such half courses, provided that they are relevant to the program of study. Students should submit a formal request, including the course syllabus, outlining how the course is relevant to their research at the Theory Centre. Requests should be submitted no later than the start of term (September 1/January 1/May 1). In order to ensure a place in the course, students must also submit a Course Outside Home Program form.
In exceptional circumstances, students may fulfill one of their six course requirements by taking a Directed Reading course. Students should, however, be aware that instructors receive no credit for teaching reading courses and may therefore be unwilling to offer them. Reading courses are given on a Pass/Fail basis, must meet for the same number of hours as a regular course, cannot be specifically oriented to the student's thesis, and will not be approved if there is a regular course that covers approximately the same material. Requests for reading courses, including syllabus, marking scheme, and letter of consent from the instructor, must be submitted no later than six weeks before the start of the term in which the course is to be taken. Please consult the Director for further details.
Language Requirements
In addition, students whose proposed program of doctoral research involves sustained work with texts originally written in a language or languages other than English will be required, after consultation with the Director and their supervisor, to demonstrate competency in the language(s) necessary for the dissertation.
There are three ways of satisfying the language requirement:
-
-
- Language Exam - For those who are fluent but whose proficiency is not reflected in formal course preparation. Students can meet the requirement in one of two ways:
- Take a written foreign language exam to demonstrate reading knowledge of a language other than English. This requirement is met by passing a translation test, to be written with the aid of a dictionary, set by the Director. Test languages are limited to the expertise and availability of faculty.
- The language department administers an online, computerized test to determine students' proficiency. Once completed, the results should be sent to the Director of the Centre for evaluation.
- Course Work - Satisfactory completion (70% or above) in a full year undergraduate language course beyond the level of senior matriculation (numbered 1900 - 4999) will be regarded as meeting the language requirement.
*Note* enrolling in an undergraduate course requires the submission of an Add Undergraduate Course form.
- Language Exam - For those who are fluent but whose proficiency is not reflected in formal course preparation. Students can meet the requirement in one of two ways:
-
- Previous Studies - students who have already satisfied the language requirement through previous post-secondary language studies may apply those course credits toward the degree requirement in Theory and Criticism. Students should consult with the Director at the beginning of the year.
-
Note: Students enrolling in language courses through the Department of Languages and Cultures may take the course Pass/Fail. You must indicate that you wish to take the course Pass/Fail at the time of enrollment and cannot be changed retroactively.
Qualifying Examinations
Ph.D. candidates are required to pass the Core Examination and Field Examination before proceeding to the doctoral dissertation. These are to be completed during the second year of study.
The Core Examination is to be taken during the second year of the Ph.D. There are two annual options for sitting the Core Examination: the first in September, and the second in February. It consists of a written examination based on a reading list of 50 books or equivalents (chapters/articles). The exam is assigned both a Pass/Fail and a numeric grade, the latter to be recorded only internally within CSTC. The student is notified of the results of the exam by the Chair of the examining committee. A candidate may fail and retake the Core Examination once. A candidate who fails the Core Examination a second time will be required to withdraw from the program.
The Field Examination is an opportunity to define an area of interdisciplinary theory related to the student’s dissertation project. It involves submission of a written text followed by an oral hearing in which this text is discussed with the student by a committee. Candidates have until May 15 of their second year to submit the written components, with the oral hearing to occur within 2-3 weeks of submission. Working with his/her supervisor and any other potential members of the advisory committee, the student will submit a 20 to 25-page text, including bibliography and synopsis. This text will be examined as part of the Field Study and is assigned a Pass/Fail. A candidate may fail and retake the Field Exam once. A candidate who passes the Core Examination but fails the Field Exam twice will be required to withdraw from the program.
A short, 4-5-page Thesis Proposal with bibliography will be due 2 weeks after the Field Study Hearing. The Thesis Proposal, in the form of a chapter outline, will be the subject of a meeting between the candidate, his/her supervisor, and second reader. Final approval of the Thesis Proposal by the Graduate Studies Committee will be understood as completion of the Field Exam milestone, and the Program's approval for the candidate to proceed with the proposed dissertation project.
Summary of Schedule - Core Exam:
- May 31 (Term 3) Date by which candidate must declare intention to take examination
- November 15 (Term 4) Date by which the candidate must meet with chair of examining committee
- September (Term 4) or February (Term 5) Examination to be taken during designated week
Core Qualifying Examination Reading List - 2023
Core Qualifying Examination Reading List - 2026
Summary of Schedule - Field Exam:
- May 31 (Term 3) Date by which candidate must declare intention to take examination
- May 15 (Term 6) Date by which candidate must submit the written components of the Field Study. The hearing date to be determined by the candidate, in consultation with supervisor and second reader. Candidate must communicate hearing date to Program Coordinator at least six (6) weeks beforehand.
Follow this link for complete Ph.D. Qualifying Examinations: Guidelines and Regulations.
Dissertation Requirements
Year II, Fall term (September - December)
During the first term of the second year of the program, the student, with the help of the Graduate Studies Committee, must choose an area of study for dissertation research and an appropriate supervisor. Although every effort will be made to accommodate a student's research preferences, the program cannot guarantee a particular supervisor. The supervisor must be a core faculty member of the Centre with the appropriate level of supervisory membership for overseeing Doctoral thesis research. SGPS regulations concerning supervisory committees can be found here.
Year IV (May - August), Dissertation
Each Ph.D. student is required to write a dissertation on an approved topic, which is expected to be an original contribution to knowledge and which will be presented in appropriate dissertation form for examination. The dissertation must be no fewer than 60,000 words, excluding bibliography and appendices, and must not exceed 100,000 words.
When the thesis is thought to meet recognized scholarly standards for the discipline and degree and is ready for examination, the Centre arranges a Thesis Examination by setting a proposed date and obtaining provisional consent from the potential members of the Thesis Examination Board, according to the General Thesis Regulations set by the School of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies' (SGPS).
Ph.D. students are required to provide a public presentation on their thesis research, normally within twenty-four hours before the thesis examination. Public lectures are distinct from the examination and the presentation occurs in an open forum.
Normally the entire process, from the Centre's request for a Thesis Examination to the placement of the candidate's name on the convocation list, requires approximately 8 weeks.
*Note* all program requirements (including language requirement) must be completed before submission of a thesis for oral examination
Satisfactory Progress
Expectations
To maintain funding eligibility within the fundable years, doctoral students must demonstrate satisfactory academic progress toward completing their degree. "Satisfactory progress" is defined as meeting all program requirements on schedule, including required coursework, the language milestone, qualifying examinations, and continuous advancement toward your dissertation defense. All research students must complete an annual Pathfinder Report to track and communicate progress to their supervisor and the program Director.
Failing to maintain satisfactory progress will result in a review by the Graduate Studies Committee (GSC). Consequences may include the termination of your funding and mandatory withdrawal from the program.
Course Work
"Satisfactory progress" is defined as meeting all course requirements on time with a grade of 78% or above.
A student may request an incomplete (INC) without penalty on compassionate or medical grounds. The student must submit a written request to the course instructor and program Director no later than the last day of classes. The request must include:
-
The reason for the request
-
The date by which the remaining work will be completed
-
A note from a doctor (only if necessary)
The Graduate Studies Committee (GSC) will review the request and make a decision. Permission from the course instructor does not guarantee that an INC request will be granted. Students are not permitted to have more than one INC in a term, unless there are extenuating circumstances. The INC will be updated to a grade once the work is confirmed complete by the course instructor. The deadline to submit work to complete an INC is the last day of the following term. If a grade is not submitted by this deadline, the INC becomes a failure, resulting in an 'F' on your transcript. The program will not re-consider a grade revision unless there is cause to do so.
Language Requirement
All doctoral students must consult with the program Director to establish a timeline for completing the language milestone. It is reccomended that you complete the language milestone by the end of your second year, or within 6 terms.
Student cannot defend their thesis and graduate if the language milestone has not been fulfilled.
Qualifying Examinations
"Satisfactory progress" is defined as completing the Qualifying Examinations within the expected timeline. This includes:
-
The completion of the Core Examination (Part 1 and Part 2) in year two, term 4 (September) or term 5 (February).
-
The completion of the Field Examination in year two, term 6. You are expected to submit the thesis proposal two weeks after the Field Examination.
Annual Progress Report - Pathfinder
All research students must complete an annual Pathfinder Report to track and communicate progress to their supervisor and the program Director.
By year three, students must submit a draft portion of the thesis. Students must discuss their draft material with their supervisor and second reader, and complete the required sections of the report before submitting it to Pathfinder for the program Director to review.
Pathfinder progress reports are required by all research students. They will be issued in the spring each year with a deadline date of July 15th.
Dissertation
"Satisfactory progress" in thesis work is defined as:
-
Choosing an area of study for dissertation research by the end of the 4th term
-
Matching with a supervisor by the end of the 4th term
-
Submiting a dissertation proposal, including bibliography, by the beginning of the 6th term
-
Passing your Thesis Defence by the end of the 12th term
Stages and Deadlines
Years I & II
Year I, May 31 (term 3)
Candidates are required to declare by May 31 (Term 3) their intention to take the core examination in either September or February of Year II (Terms 4 and 5). Candidates are also required to declare their intention to take the Field Exam. This should be done in writing to the Program Coordinator.
Year II, Fall (term 4)
During the first term of the second year of the program (September - December), the student, with the help of the Graduate Studies Committee, must choose an area of study for dissertation research and an appropriate supervisor. This should be done in writing to the Program Coordinator.
Year II - September or February
Year II - May 15
Candidates have until May 15 (Term 6) of their second year to submit the written components of the Field Examination, with the oral hearing to occur within 2-3 weeks of submission. The three components (20-25 page text, bibliography and synopsis) must be submitted no less than two weeks prior to the oral hearing.
The hearing date is determined by the candidate, in consultation with the supervisor and second reader. A short, 4-5-page Thesis Proposal will be due 2 weeks after the Field Study Hearing. Final approval of the Thesis Proposal by the Graduate Studies Committee will be understood as completion of the Field Examination milestone.
Year II, June
Year III - June
Submitting the Pathfinder portfolio is considered a degree requirement, and to maintain good standing in a program it must be completed by June of each year.
Year IV (May - August)
Each Ph.D. student is required to write a dissertation between 60,000 - 100,000 words. When the thesis is thought to meet recognized scholarly standards for the discipline and degree and is ready for defense, the Centre arranges a Thesis Examination with potential members of the Thesis Examination Board, and the School of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies' (SGPS).
Satisfactory progress consists of successful completion of the Thesis Examination by the 12th term of registration (August 31 of Year IV).